Got an Income Tax “Mismatch” Email? How to Read Your AIS, Fix the Error and Avoid a Real Notice
Devyani Khandekar, a 44-year-old pathologist in Kolhapur, opened her inbox one evening to find an email from the Income Tax Department. No scary red letters, no summons. Just a quiet line saying her return for the year didn’t appear to match certain information the department already had. She read it twice, assumed it was spam, and nearly deleted it.
It wasn’t spam. It was what the department now calls a “nudge,” a soft heads-up sent before anything turns into an actual notice. I’m Bhanu Pratap Singh, and this piece walks through what these emails mean, how to check whether yours is something to worry about, and what to do in the days right after you get one.
A nudge is not a notice
There’s a real difference between the two, and it changes how you should react.
A nudge or intimation is an early, informal signal. It usually arrives by email or SMS, tells you that something in your Annual Information Statement (AIS) doesn’t line up with what you declared, and invites you to check and correct it yourself before the filing deadline or through an updated return. It carries no section number, no demand, and no deadline to “reply or else.”
A notice is formal. It cites a specific section of the Income Tax Act, usually arrives through the income tax e-filing portal under “e-Proceedings,” and carries a response deadline that has real consequences if missed.
The department itself has said more than once that a high-value transaction, on its own, doesn’t trigger a notice. It triggers a question. Whether that question grows into something formal depends entirely on how you respond to it.
Treat a nudge as a free chance to fix something before it becomes the second kind. Ignoring it doesn’t erase the mismatch. It just means the department finds it the hard way later, usually with less patience.
Where this data comes from
None of this is random. Banks, registrars, mutual fund houses and others are required to report certain transactions to the department through something called a Statement of Financial Transaction (SFT, sometimes still called Form 61A reporting). These feed directly into your AIS.
A few of the common triggers, based on current reporting rules:
| Transaction | Reporting threshold |
|---|---|
| Cash deposits in a savings account | Aggregating to ₹10 lakh or more in a year |
| Fixed or recurring deposits (new, not renewals) | Aggregating to ₹10 lakh or more in a year |
| Cash deposits or withdrawals in a current account | Aggregating to ₹50 lakh or more in a year |
| Large mutual fund investments, share purchases, property deals | Reported individually above the thresholds set for each category |
Crossing a threshold doesn’t mean you did anything wrong. It just means the department now has a data point, and it expects your return to make sense next to it.
What usually causes the mismatch
In most cases it isn’t fraud. It’s a gap between what a third party reported and what actually went into your return.
- Interest income left out. Savings account interest, FD interest, or even an income tax refund that itself carries interest, often sits quietly in AIS and gets forgotten at filing time.
- Salary figures that don’t tie up. The number in your ITR differs slightly from what your employer’s TDS return or Form 16 shows.
- A big-ticket purchase with no visible income behind it. A property or a large mutual fund investment that looks disproportionate to your declared income for the year.
- TDS credit claimed that doesn’t match Form 26AS or AIS.
- Business turnover that doesn’t match GST filings, where GSTR-1 or GSTR-3B shows more revenue than the ITR does.
Real Example: Omkar Raut, 38, runs a small electronics repair business in Kolhapur. His AIS showed a property purchase of ₹42 lakh during the year. His declared income for that year and the two years before it, taken together, could reasonably support only about ₹18 lakh of that. Part of the gap was a loan he’d taken, and part was savings from years he hadn’t filed returns carefully for. The email simply asked him to look again. It wasn’t an accusation, but it was a fair question.
Six steps for the week you get the email
Step 1: Don’t click anything inside the email itself. Open a new browser tab and go to the income tax portal directly. Phishing emails copy this exact wording, so never trust a link pasted into the message.
Step 2: Log in and open your AIS. On the portal, go to Services, then Annual Information Statement. It shows two views: AIS (the full detail) and TIS (Taxpayer Information Summary, a simplified, category-wise total). Start with TIS for the overview, then drill into AIS for the exact entries. The department’s own AIS information page explains both views if you want the source rather than a blog’s version.
Step 3: Match every flagged entry against your own records. Pull up your bank statements, Form 16, your Form 26AS from the TRACES portal, and any investment or property documents. Our bank statement guide is useful here, since bank-paid interest (the INT.PD line) is one of the most commonly missed items in AIS checks.
Step 4: Decide, for each entry, which feedback option fits. The AIS feedback mechanism gives you a short menu for each line:
| Feedback option | When to choose it |
|---|---|
| Information is correct | The entry is yours and accurate |
| Information is not fully correct | It’s yours, but an amount, date or category is wrong |
| Information relates to other PAN or year | It belongs to someone else, or a different financial year |
| Information is duplicate | The same transaction appears twice |
| Information is denied | You’re certain it has nothing to do with you |
Step 5: Correct your return, if needed. If the AIS entry is accurate and you simply missed reporting it, you generally have two routes: revise your original return if the deadline for that hasn’t passed, or file an updated return (ITR-U) if it has.
Step 6: Keep a record of everything you submit. Screenshot the feedback you gave, save the acknowledgement, and file it with your tax papers for that year. If the department circles back months later, you’ll want to show exactly what you said and when.
A note on cash, and where it tends to come from
Not every flagged entry is interest or a stray investment. For a lot of self-employed people and small traders, the flag is cash itself: a deposit pattern that looks like it’s being made in careful, round pieces rather than naturally. If you run a business, this is worth cross-checking against your GST filings too, since a mismatch between what you’ve reported to GST and what shows up in your bank deposits is one of the more common triggers on the business side. Our GST Calculator can help you sanity-check the tax portion of large deposits before you decide how to respond to a flagged entry.
If you took a loan to fund a large purchase that’s now showing up as unexplained in your AIS, keep the loan sanction letter and the disbursal entry handy. It’s one of the simplest ways to explain a gap between declared income and a big-ticket transaction, the way Omkar did above. If the loan itself carried a guarantor, remember that the guarantor’s liability doesn’t disappear once your loan is sanctioned and running smoothly; loan guarantor guide is worth a read if that applies to your situation, since it’s a separate risk that a tax mismatch can sometimes bring back into focus when lenders start asking questions of their own.
The ITR-U route, and what it costs
An updated return under Section 139(8A) lets you declare income you missed, even after your original and revised return deadlines have passed. It isn’t free, and the cost rises the longer you wait.
| Filed within | Extra tax on top of tax and interest due |
|---|---|
| 12 months of the relevant assessment year ending | 25% |
| 24 months | 50% |
| 36 months | 60% |
| 48 months | 70% |
Real Example: Suhasini Bhujbal, 29, a schoolteacher in Wardha, had missed reporting about ₹15,400 of FD interest for a year. Once she worked out the tax owed on that interest at her slab rate, it came to roughly ₹3,200. Filing an ITR-U within the first window would have cost her an extra 25% of her total tax and interest due, not 25% of the interest alone. On a small base like hers, the final number stayed modest, but the lesson holds for anyone with a bigger gap: the earlier you file, the cheaper the correction.
There are limits on when you can use ITR-U. Generally, you can’t use it to claim a refund, increase a loss, reduce your total tax liability, or file one if you’re already under investigation or assessment for that year. It exists to let you pay what you owe, with a penalty, not to reopen your return in your favour.
When the email is really about someone else
Sometimes the mismatch isn’t your mistake at all.
Real Example: Anirudh Phadke, 51, found a mutual fund transaction flagged in his AIS that belonged to his late father’s folio, still linked to an old joint PAN detail from years ago. He didn’t need to amend his return. He simply selected “Information relates to other PAN or year” for that entry and attached a short note explaining the folio history. No tax was due, and no further contact followed.
This is common enough that it’s worth checking carefully before you assume a flagged entry is actually yours. A joint account, an old business partnership, or a family member’s transaction can land in the wrong AIS by a data-matching error on the reporting entity’s side.
It’s also worth checking your AIS against money you’ve moved for genuinely safe reasons. If part of a large credit in your AIS came from an insurance policy you cancelled within its free-look window, that refund can look, on paper, like an unexplained large receipt. Our guide to bank-sold insurance and free-look cancellations covers how those refunds work, and keeping the cancellation letter alongside your tax papers saves you from having to reconstruct the story a year later.
If a real notice follows
Occasionally a nudge is ignored, or the department decides the gap needs a formal answer anyway, and a notice under a specific section arrives. At that point:
- Read the section quoted and the exact question being asked. Don’t answer more than what’s asked.
- Respond only through the e-Proceedings tab on the portal, in writing, with dates.
- If the amount involved is significant, or the notice relates to a search or survey, get a chartered accountant involved rather than replying on your own.
- Never ignore the stated deadline. A notice that goes unanswered tends to escalate faster than one that gets even a basic, honest response.
A small prevention habit
The best way to avoid these emails is to check your AIS once, mid-year, rather than only at filing time. Log in around October or November, well before the rush, and look for anything that’s accumulated since the last return. Interest income, in particular, tends to sit there quietly until it’s too late to fix cheaply.
If you also run an SWP (Systematic Withdrawal Plan) from a mutual fund for regular income, remember that each withdrawal can generate a small capital gain, and that gain shows up in AIS too, even when the bulk of the withdrawal is simply your own capital returning to you. Our SWP guide explains how that gain is actually calculated, which makes it much easier to recognise the entry when it turns up on your statement instead of mistaking it for unexplained income.
Checklist
□ I checked the sender was the actual income tax portal, not a lookalike email.
□ I logged in directly rather than clicking a link in the email.
□ I compared AIS against my bank statements, Form 16 and 26AS.
□ I gave feedback on every flagged entry, not just the biggest one.
□ I decided whether a revised return or ITR-U is needed.
□ I saved a screenshot of every feedback I submitted.
□ I know this isn’t a demand notice unless it quotes a section number.
Common questions
Is an AIS mismatch email the same as an income tax notice?
No. It’s an informal nudge. A formal notice quotes a specific section and arrives through e-Proceedings on the portal.Does crossing a reporting threshold mean I’ll be taxed extra?
No. It just means the transaction was reported. Tax is owed only on income, not on the act of depositing or investing money you’ve already paid tax on.What if the AIS entry genuinely isn’t mine?
Select “Information relates to other PAN or year” or “Information is denied,” whichever fits, and keep your explanation on record.How long do I have to file an ITR-U?
Up to 48 months from the end of the relevant assessment year, with the extra tax rising the longer you wait.Can an ITR-U get me a refund?
No, it can’t be used to claim a refund or reduce your tax liability. It’s meant for paying more, not less.The last word
Devyani’s email turned out to be a forgotten FD her bank had opened automatically from a sweep-in facility, with interest she hadn’t tracked. Ten minutes on the portal, one piece of feedback, and it was done. If you take one thing from me, Bhanu Pratap Singh, let it be this: these emails are usually smaller than they sound, but only if you open them the same week, not the same year.
Disclaimer
This is general information, not tax or legal advice. Reporting thresholds, AIS feedback options, ITR-U rules and the department’s practices change over time, and the names and amounts in the examples are invented. Check your own AIS, the official income tax portal, and a qualified chartered accountant before you act.
